
I’ve actually got a few more things to say, as I sit here eating my cookie dough ice cream (yeah, things are going about as well as you suspect).
To be clear, I do enjoy watching The Secret and I do employ many of the techniques described with great success. I’ve actually done so for about 7 years now, after reading about the same techniques from other sources (metaphysical books). Now that these ideas have nearly fully moved into mainstream pop culture, I’m worried over the ways I see this “new secret” being perverted.
I believe that The Secret inappropriately places blame on the individual for things which may truly be outside their control. For example, there is a story in the movie of a woman that gets breast cancer, and then wills herself to be completely healed by “just laughing.” It is fine and good to explore the idea that people can help their bodies to heal by having a positive attitude and reducing their stress, this is a well established fact and not one that is presented for the first time in this movie, but there is a very subtle insinuation here that people may be attracting disease through their thoughts. Indeed, throughout the movie Bob Proctor continues to repeat “the power of attraction” and the idea that we attract both good and bad things into our lives.
The idea that people could begin to blame themselves, or others, for disease didn’t really hit home until today when a good friend (who is an avid folower of The Secret, among other metaphysical ideas) actually tried to blame me for my current cold. When I said that no, it’s not in my head because I took my temperature and it was 102, I was actually told that I must have attracted that disease through negative thoughts.
This just sort of instantly seemed proposterous to me, that someone would choose this explanation first. Being aware of Ockham’s razor, the idea that “All things being equal, the simplest solution tends to be the best one,” I would first go with the idea that either a cold virus or a bacteria had taken temporary hold in my body. This is a well established fact, and ludicrous that I would need to prove it to someone in the year 2007.
“But you may have attracted that virus to you with your negative thoughts.” Well, ok…I think you can see where this is headed. The avid follower of The Secret always has a way out of the debate because, no matter what you say to him, he can say that you attracted that whatever to you, and can enjoy sounding like he knows the mystical ways of the universe without needing to provide proof of anything. Sound familiar? Think Christianity…or any other traditional organized religion.
This was a relatively lighthearted discussion, because we are after all talking about a simple cold. But would he say this to someone who has cancer? HIV? Alzheimers?
The Secret fails to recognize that we all play a huge part in the health, wealth and happiness of others. By making you believe that you have the power to have anything, heal anything, do anything…well, what is the point in any sort of philanthropy? Why should we invest in medical research, social programs, national security? Would you be willing to argue that all of the victims of the recent terror attacks attracted that fate to themselves?
The Secret has, in my opinion, started a dangerous trend of blame and absolution of responsibility to others. Sound familiar? Think the Republican Party…or any other modern conservative movement.
There are some really good concepts in The Secret and, to be fair, I don’t believe the movie goes (or wants to go) as far as I’ve portrayed it here. However, I do believe that the concepts have been perverted by the masses who are now aware of it and are using it for purely self gain.
Recent Comments