Alright, I’ve just about had it with the lunacy that surrounds the illegal immigration debate. I get going about this quite often, but today I read a story that was linked from Drudge, titled “Study: Illegal immigration costs border counties millions.”
I was actually really intrigued by this, and wondered if it had in fact been proven that illegal immigration costs taxpayers as much as the conservative activists would have us believe. So, I clicked onto the story and began reading. Here’s the entire story, that had been reprinted from The Arizona Republic:
Study: Illegal immigration costs border counties millions
PHOENIX (AP) - A new study concludes that law enforcement and criminal prosecutions linked to illegal immigration is costing Arizona border counties millions of dollars a year.
The study says the battle over illegal immigration is also diverting money from parks, libraries and other law-enforcement efforts.
University of Arizona and San Diego State University researchers say in the four border counties in Arizona, costs increased 39% to $26.6 million in fiscal 2006.
The study was commissioned by the U.S.-Mexico Border Counties Coalition, a non-profit group of border-county officials.
Do you see what they did here? I hope you do, because this is really typical of how this debate is manipulated. The title of the story insinuates that illegal immigrants are a drain on our public resources - you know, like healthcare, education and other benefits that get discussed often in reference to the overall debate. In fact the title does more than insinuate it, it pretty much lets you believe that the very act of illegal immigration costs us millions.
But that’s not what the study proves. The study concludes that PROSECUTING illegal immigrants for being here is costing us millions. Actually it doesn’t really prove anything that’s difficult to believe, as I think anyone knows that prosecuting them and deporting them is going to cost something. The “study” just adds up the numbers. But I think you can see that most people who read this would get a different impression if they don’t think carefully about the language here. They are going to think that illegal immigrants costs us money just by being here, and that’s just not the case.
Those who are adamantly opposed to illegal immigration and support drastic measures to curb it are, quite seriously, lying to you about the facts and are simply trying to hide their own racism.
Healthcare
Opponents want you to believe that illegal immigrants are responsible for our out of control healthcare costs because they use up free services at hospital emergency rooms. While partially true, they are not responsible for the vast majority of this problem - Americans are. The fact is that nearly 50 million Americans don’t have health insurance, either. But this argument completely ignores the fact that many will pay for care at clinics, just like other uninsured people do. Regardless, if controlling healthcare costs were really a concern for one of these people, they would address the biggest problem - which is uninsured Americans. But that’s not their concern.
Education
Opponents want you to believe that illegal immigrants are responsible for our poor education spending and quality. This is not true because, as you know, schools are mostly funded by property taxes. Even though a family may be illegal, they are living somewhere that is owned by someone - and taxes are being paid by that owner. Illegal immigrants are no more responsible for grabbing an unfair percentage of education spending than anyone else who rents a residence instead of owns one. Besides that, even if it were true wouldn’t it be balanced out by the 10% of the population who are gay and pays to fund their local schools even though they don’t commonly have children? If we got really technical here, I could also craft a sound argument that Walmart is a drain on our public services. But that’s not their concern, either.
Circular Reasoning
Of course the crux of these and other arguments is that since their employment is not legitimate, they do not (cannot) pay taxes, and thus do not properly contribute to the society in which they live. I’ll give them that. So let’s legitimize their employment! So they can pay taxes! No? What, why not? Oh, because they are a drain and do not properly contribute to our tax system. Huh? Do you see the circular reasoning?
So, what’s the real concern here? I’ll tell you what it is, because everyone who argues against immigration with me is thinking the same damn thing.
The strong opponents of immigration don’t like looking at Mexicans and think they’re dirty. They think they have too many babies and spread illness. They think they have ugly houses and drive old cars. They think that they all have a knife or gun on them, and do drugs all day. They think that they all want to open up little shops on their business corners that will be roasting chiles all day and selling tamales in bags by the side of the road in ragged clothing.
Can we have the real argument now?
Recent Comments